What a nice Italian gem in the Castleton / Keystone area. Fine dining, linens, piano music and tuxedoed staff, all Italian style. The calamari is authentic and amazing for an appetizer. Bread at the table - piping hot. Pasta is entirely made on site. Worth the extra price - a very nice experience! And easy parking and convenient location.

Delicious house made pasta! I recommend the mushroom stuffed ravioli. Yum! Very nice ambiance-- the Saturday evening we were there had a lovely musical combo playing (we could still hear each other). The waiter was very good & suggested wines which he gave samples. They also have a market available. Reservations are recommended especially for the evening.

The food was excellent and the prices are fair. A perfect restaurant for a date night. Great service and a great selection of wines. The concept of this restaurant is unique- they make their own Pasta, sauces, cheese and desserts. Highly recommend this restaurant!!!

Wow, the food is tremendous! It exceeded what were high expectations based on the great reviews we read before going. Everything was really fresh and delicious and cooked to perfection. If you can, save room for the cannoli cake, it was really good. If not, get it to go from the deli. I can't wait to go back!

We tried out Catellos during Devour Indy. Service was prompt. Menu is varied. We started with the traditional meat/cheese tray. Ample servings for 2 people! Fresh warm bread. I had the mushroom ravioli!! Outstanding. Generous portions. Lemon sorbet for desert was on point. Salad and lasagna also well done. We cant wait to go back!